Jump to content

Talk:List of Gulag camps

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Old talk

[edit]

Hi there! Is this part of a series? Is there some reason for a list specific to Poles? Did these camps only detain Poles, or were their populations mixed? Thanks! Mark Richards 06:06, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)

The work with articles barely started. Mikkalai 08:42, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)
The list comes from the Polish law. I think it is the most complete list of GULAGS we can have here. I have no intention of keeping the list Polish-exclusive. Non-Polish people also had "pleasure" to be hosted there. Cautious 13:37, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)
Then shouldn't it be titled List of Gulag camps? Why mention Poles in the title at all? Thanks! Mark Richards 19:06, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)
When done, we'll see for the proper name. Not to say, it needs significant clean-up. Be patient. Mikkalai 20:42, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)
When you say 'done', what do you mean exactly? What do you think needs to be done to this page before that determination can be made? How long do you think that might take? Thanks! Mark Richards 20:44, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)
First of all, it is necessary to figure out what exactly this list is, besides what is defined by the title. At the moment, the title is exact, but the utility of the list may go beyond that. Why do you keep asking all these questions everywhere? Are you a kapo behind my back? Take ten, man. Mikkalai 21:29, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)

'Kapo'? Not sure what you mean, I was asking questions because I am interested. I'm kind of confused by what you mean bu figuring out exactly what the list is, since you seem to have written most of it - don't be offended, just trying to learn! Mark Richards 21:55, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Kapo is a prisoner, that violently leads a team of prisoners. The worst traitor, deserves death more then guards. The whole list was copied over from the Polish law. I think the list was created by some historians working for Polish government, to verify retirenment rights of former prisoners. Somebody can claim, i.e. that he was imprisoned in concentration camp Washington DC, but then he can be verified by the list of actually existing camps. Logically derived conclusion says, the list should include all existing camps. Cautious 08:42, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Kapo: not necessarily as you write. Many kapos were actually convicted criminals. Is kapo was, say, a thief or a crook, he was pretty easy on the Arbeitskommando. Mikkalai 09:12, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)
I fail to see how this detour of abuse gets at the key question of why this list is titled as it is. Mark Richards 16:09, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)
Maybe because of bad luck? Maybe because Poles were in each of those camps? I would prefer to discuss the page of concentration camps for i.e. Belgians, but unfortunately history happenned otherwise. Anyway, the list of camp for Poles maybe usefull in some history articles. I think, if we group them in list of less then 20 items, then at the end we can have a list for Poles and the complete list. It is obvious that some could be missing. I am not sure i.e. Solovki. Are they present? Cautious 16:22, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)
I'm not sure what you mean by bad luck - you're not claiming that any of these camps detained only Poles, so let's change the name, and describe which groups were detained in the article Mark Richards 16:51, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)
Hey that's great - I feel a whole lot better about the list - can we do the same for the other similar ones? Thanks~ Mark Richards 17:13, 10 Mar 2004 (UTC)

I am traslating these names from derived adjectives in Polish, and most of these obscure Siberian and Kazakstan non-Russian names just pop up in my memory in proper Russian spelling. And mind you, it is not that I am a geography freak or something. It is simply over years all these place names flooded Soviet newspapers as sites of "Great Communist (or Komsomol) Construction Works (no mentions of labor camps, of course... ).

To do

[edit]

Linked: Karlag, Norillag, Steplag, not yet: Ozyorlag, Gorlag, Siblag, Khakasslag, Minerallag, Yuzhkuzbasslag, Sevurallag (Sverdlovsk obl), Ussollag (Perm obl),

list

[edit]

from http://memorial.kiev.ua/expo/eng/perelik.html 1 Abakanlag C-11 2 Abezlag B-8 3 Aldanlag В-14 4 Aktiubinsklag C-7 5 Aimlag C-15 6 Alma-Atalag D-9 7 Akmolalag C-9 8 Allaikhalag A-16 9 Andizhanlag D-9 10 Angarlag B-12 11 Astrakhanlag D-6 12 Azbestlag C-8 13 Ashalag C-8 14 Arkhangelsklag C-8 15 Aiaklag C-15 16 Bakulag D-6 17 Bakinska per. D-17 18 Baligichailag C-7 19 Bashkirialag C-7 20 Berezevolag C-8 21 Belushelag B-6 22 Bilomorsklag F-5 23 Birobidzhanlag D-15 24 Bodoaibolag C-13 25 Borovichilag C-5 26 Bureialag D-15 27 Biugiukelag C-14 28 Vaigachlag A-7 29 Vanzevatlag B-8 30 Vereshchagino C-11 31 Vereshchaginolag C-16 32 Virkhne-Imbats. B-10 33 Volgo-Don D-6 34 Vladivostok D-15 35 Velsklag B-6 36 Verkhoiansklag B-15 37 Verkhne-Urals. C-7 38 Verknii-Ufal. C-7 39 Viliuisklag B-14 40 Vitimlag C-13 41 Vologdalag C-5 42 Volkhovlag C-5 43 Vorkutalag B-8 44 Vitegralag B-5 45 Veslianalag B-7 46 Gorkiilag C-6 47 Dzhezkazganlag D-8 48 Donbaslag D-5 49 Yelabuglag D-7 50 Zhigansklag C-14 51 Zaiarsklag C-12 52 Zemlia Fr-Yosyf S-8 53 Ivanovlag C-6 54 Irkutska Gr. L. C-12 55 Ivdellag B-8 56 Irgizlag D-8 57 Izhevsklag C-7 58 Imanlag D-15 59 Irkutsklag C-12 60 Ishimbailag C-7 61 Kazalinsklag D-8 62 Kizellag C-7 63 Kozhbalag B-8 64 Kolpashevolag C-10 65 Kyngirlag D-9 66 Kokchetavlag C-6 67 Krasnouralsk C-8 68 Kurialag C-13 69 Kustanailag C-8 70 Kaganlag C-13 71 Kazanlag C-6 72 Krasnyi Luch D-5 73 Karagandalag D-9 74 Katalag C-11 75 Kostromalag C-6 76 Kirovobadlag D-8 77 Kolymalag B-17 78 Kamchatkalag C-17 79 Kandalakshalag B-5 80 Karakaslag D-10 81 Karaullag B-10 82 Kargopollag B-5 83 Kemerovolag C-10 84 Kuznetsklag C-10 85 Kzil-Ordalag D-8 86 Kirovlag C-6 87 Komandorovsk. C-18 88 Komsomolsklag C-15 89 Kopeisklag C-8 90 Kotlaslag B-6 91 Krasnovodsk C-11 92 Kranoturins. C-8 93 Krasnoiarsklag C-11 94 Kuibyshevlag C-7 95 Kuloilag B-6 96 Kungurlag C-7 97 Kurgan-Tiubel. D-9 98 Kurilsk isl. D-17 99 Kizillag C-11 100 Leningradlag B-5 101 Leninogorsklag C-10 102 Maior-Krestil. C-16 103 Mirnoelag B-10 104 Monchegorskl. B-5 105 Magdagachilag C-14 106 Magadanlag C-17 107 Minichevanlag C-10 108 Minichevolag D-6 109 Mordovian ASSR C-6 110 Magnitogorsk C-7 111 Mariiskaia ASSR C-6 112 Mariinsklag C-10 113 Makhachkalag D-6 114 Medvezhegorsk B-5 115 Mezenlag B-6 116 Miaslag C-7 117 Molotovlag C-7 118 Morshansklag C-5 119 Moskva C-5 120 Narimlag C-10 121 Nizhni Khrestil. C-18 122 Nizhnii Tagill. C-7 123 *Norilsklag C-10 124 Nizhnie Tambovs. C-15 125 Nova Zemlia isl. A-8 126 Novosibirsklag C-10 127 Nordviklag A-13 128 Nalchiklag D-6 129 Narian-Marlag B-7 130 Nikolaievsklag C-16 131 Olemkinsklag B-14 132 Ozhoginolag B-14 133 Omsklag C-9 134 Orsklag C-7 135 Ostashkovlag C-5 136 Penzalag C-6 137 Pidkam. Tunguz. C-11 138 Pomorilag C-10 139 Prokop'evsklag C-10 140 Pokchalag B-7 141 Pervouralsklag C-7 142 Petrozavodsk B-5 143 Petropavlovs. C-8 144 *Pechoralag B-7 145 Plesetsklag B-6 146 Ramenskoelag C-5 147 Revdalag B-5 148 Rezhlag C-8 149 Rugozerolag B-5 150 *Salekhardlag B-8 151 Sverdlovsklag C-8 152 Volgogradlag D-6 153 Sakhalinlag C-16 154 Solikamsklag C-7 155 Spasklag D-15 156 Donetskelag D-5 157 Novokuznetsklag C-10 158 Sukhobezvodnoe C-6 159 Saraklag D-9 160 Salianlag D-6 161 Saransklag C-6 162 Segezhalag B-5 163 Semipalatins. C-10 164 Solovetsky isl. B-5 165 Sortavalalag B-5 166 Sretensklag C-13 167 Savinborlag B-7 168 Seimchanlag B-17 169 Sered. Kolyms. B-17 170 Stanchiklag A-17 171 Stolbovoelag D-15 172 Siktivkarlag B-7 173 Starodublag C-5 174 Suoiarvilag B-5 175 Sukhumilag D-6 176 Suchaklag D-15 177 Sizranlag C-6 178 *Tavdalag C-8 179 Taigalag C-10 180 Taldilag D-9 181 Tebuliakhlag A-17 182 Totmalag C-6 183 Turinsklag C-8 184 *Taishetlag C-11 185 *Tashkentlag D-8 186 Tiflislag D-6 187 Tetiushilag C-6 188 Tiksilag A-14 189 Tikhvinlag B-5 190 Tobolsklag C-8 191 Tomsklag C-10 192 Tulalag C-5 193 Turvlag B-11 194 Turkestanlag D-8 195 Turukhansklag B-10 196 Tiumenlag C-8 197 Usollag C-12 198 Ust-Vorkutalag B-8 199 Ust-Kamchats. C-18 200 Ust-Kulomlag B-7 201 Ust-Portlag A-10 202 Ust-Srednika. B-17 203 Ust-Usalag B-7 204 Ust-Shchugorlag B-7 205 Uglichlag C-5 206 Ulianovsklag C-6 207 Ulan-Ude t.p. C-12 208 Uralsklag C-7 209 Ust-Kam'ianog. C-10 210 Ust-Vimlag B-7 211 Ust-Millag C-15 212 *Ust-Ukhtalag B-7 213 Ufalag B-7 214 Ferganalag D-9 215 Frunzelag D-9 216 Khomulag B-16 217 Khabarovsklag D-15 218 Kholmogorlag B-6 219 Chunalag C-11 220 Chukotkalag B-20 221 Chardzhoblag D-8 222 Cheliabinsklag C-8 223 Chitalag C-13 224 Chkalovlag C-7 225 Shchadrinsklag B-8 226 Shcherbakovlag C-5 227 Yakutsklag B-14 228 Yaroslavllag C-5 229 Ямалаг D-5 230 Khalmer'iulag B-8

Citation from above source:"Concentration camps organized by Moscow"? And no links in support? And who is the author of this statement? Website? Webmaster? Any date of this statement? Is it notorious author cited in other works? Any editorial policy of this website? Who are exactly at the editorial board of this website? 87.252.225.13 (talk) 17:45, 26 February 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Clarity

[edit]

I'm not quite sure what you mean by "not figured out yet." This list doesn't read easily.

The following bullet-item doesn't make much sense.

The particular groups that were imprisoned there: * Any person convicted to a term of imprisonment of more than 3 years (all those convicted to less than three years were to be sent to "corrective labor colonies").

There was difference between "camp" and "colony". `'mikka 22:33, 22 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Comment moved from article to here

[edit]

I've removed the warning below about the external link to http://www.memo.ru/history/NKVD/GULAG/maps/ussri.htm from the article - the warning seems to be incorrect (memo.ru at SiteAdvisor - TB (talk) 21:36, 4 July 2009 (UTC)[reply]

[[Please, avoid this site. McAfee Site Advisor strongly discourages its view. There are reasons to believe this is good advice.]--Ongnoi1314 (talk) 08:01, 1 July 2009 (UTC)][reply]

[edit]

Hello fellow Wikipedians,

I have just modified one external link on List of Gulag camps. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. I made the following changes:

When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.

This message was posted before February 2018. After February 2018, "External links modified" talk page sections are no longer generated or monitored by InternetArchiveBot. No special action is required regarding these talk page notices, other than regular verification using the archive tool instructions below. Editors have permission to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the RfC before doing mass systematic removals. This message is updated dynamically through the template {{source check}} (last update: 5 June 2024).

  • If you have discovered URLs which were erroneously considered dead by the bot, you can report them with this tool.
  • If you found an error with any archives or the URLs themselves, you can fix them with this tool.

Cheers.—InternetArchiveBot (Report bug) 03:14, 18 May 2017 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:List_of_Gulag_camps&oldid=1208053463"